When we first launched Tidy Casa, we were all in on DIY cleaning products. Eco-friendly, safe for families, and super affordable—what’s not to love, right?
But as we started cleaning hundreds of homes a month, we had to rethink our approach.
Here’s the honest breakdown from someone who’s been on both sides of the spray bottle:
💰 Is It Cheaper to Make Your Own Cleaning Products?
Short answer: Yes. Big time.
Let’s take glass cleaner as an example.
Homemade version:
-
1 part rubbing alcohol
-
1 part distilled white vinegar
-
4 parts water
Cost? About $0.15 for a full 32 oz bottle.
Now compare that to a store-bought Windex bottle, which runs around $4.17.
That’s a savings ratio of nearly 28 to 1. You could make 28 bottles of homemade glass cleaner for the cost of a single Windex! Of course, does not count the cost of the bottle but still… the savings are hard to beat!
✅ Pros of Making Your Own Cleaners
-
Major Cost Savings – Like we said, $0.15 vs $4.17 per bottle adds up fast.
-
Avoid Harsh Chemicals – You control what goes into your cleaners. No weird stuff you can’t pronounce, just simple ingredients from your pantry.
⚠️ Cons of DIY Cleaners
-
Inconsistent Results – Let’s be real: name-brand cleaners work better. They’re engineered with powerful ingredients for a reason. When we used DIY-only in the early days, customers noticed—and complained. That’s why we now use pro-grade cleaners unless someone specifically requests eco-friendly.
-
Takes Time – Mixing your own solution takes effort. You’ve got to store the ingredients, mix them properly, and maybe label bottles so you don’t forget what’s what.
🧼 So What’s the Best Option?
It comes down to what you value:
-
Want to save money and reduce exposure to chemicals? Go DIY.
-
Want a grab-and-go solution that guarantees results? Stick with store-bought.
At Tidy Casa, we offer both options—because cleaning should be about what works best for you.
Want to learn more about the cleaning products we use?
Or need help keeping your home fresh without lifting a finger?
Book your next cleaning today at tidycasa.com.
We’ll bring the elbow grease—homemade or not. 💪